Home > Reading Room > Dispute


« Return to Reading Room

Partial Victory for Aldi at top Irish court

Written by Laura Cannon- Solent University student on 30 May 2019

It has been announced today (30th May) that the Irish Supreme court has delivered a mixed verdict in a trademark infringement suit brought by German supermarket Aldi against Irish competitor Dunnes Stores.
Read More »

Photographer sues Clorox over cat portraits

Written by Laura Cannon- Solent University student on 24 April 2019

On Tuesday 16th April a Law suit was filed by photographer Jill Greenberg who claims the advertising agency Dentsu McGarry Bowen and the consumer product manufacturer the Clorox Company allegedly misused licensed portraits of cats on glass.
Read More »

Spotify v Apple: Antitrust complaint filed

Written by Ellis Sweetenham on 15 March 2019

Music streaming giant Spotify has filed a claim against Apple, which states that Apple’s App store rules ‘limit choice and stifle innovation at the expense of the user’.
Read More »

Don't mess with Ole Gunnar Solskjær

Written by Michael Coyle on 10 March 2019

The babyfaced assassin is not only working miracles at the Theatre of Dreams but his moral compass is unquestionable as he threatens to use the betting company Paddy Power for using an image to pass off their services without his permission. Meanwhile.....https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8fyjm5yifM
Read More »

Apple v Norwegian Political Party Logo Dispute

Written by Sena Tokel, Student from Southampton Solent University on 06 March 2019

Norwegian Progress Party Fremskrittspartiet’s red apple logo has been contested by tech giant Apple Inc with claims that the two apples will cause confusion.
Read More »

Kim Kardashian-West sued for $423 million over iconic ‘Kimojis’

Written by Demi- Leigh Mason, a student at Southampton Solent University on 15 February 2019

A lawsuit was filed in an Oklahoma federal court against Kim Kardashian-West and her company, known as Kimsaprincess Inc, regarding a series of images and emojis, known as ‘Kimojis’ by a social-media application developer.
Read More »

Lachaux v Independent Print, defamation and the serious harm test

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 08 November 2018

Next week, 13th and 14th November to be exact, the Supreme Court will hear the case of Lachaux (Respondent) v Independent Print Limited and another (Appellants) UKSC 2017/0175. The case is an appeal by Independent Print Limited from the decision at first instance as the Court of Appeal decided not to grant permission to appeal and upheld the decision.
Read More »

Ali’s Image Use: SETTLED!

Written by Leanne Davies on 20 July 2018

On Monday 16th July. A notification of settlement was filed at the US District Court for the Northern District of California, Oakland Division, concerning the use of Muhammad Ali’s image, by Fox Broadcasting.
Read More »

An uber good win for Uber

Written by Mark Reed on 26 June 2018

The appeal has been heard after the Transport for London’s decision not to renew Uber’s license because of security and public safety.
Read More »

Johnny Depp is suing the Sun for defamation

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 13 June 2018

Johnny Depp needs no introduction, the American actor, producer and musician has won the Golden Globe Award and been nominated for three Academy Awards, and now, another achievement – suing the Sun newspaper
Read More »

Final Passage for Pimlico

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 June 2018

Charlie Mullins' Pimlico Plumbers today lost a landmark Supreme Court workers' right case against a self-employed gas engineer. Gary Smith suffered a heart attack in 2011 and having worked since 2005 for Mullins sought benefits such as sick pay. He was sacked and Mullins claimed ( Big Brexiteer btw) that he was self employed.
Read More »

Prick Tattoos v Prick Cactus Shop passing off dispute

Written by Mark Reed on 04 June 2018

A dispute arose between two business claiming the use of the word ‘Prick’ in the title of their shops. Henry Martinez is a tattoo artist and Gynelle Leon is the Director of a company called Prick me baby one more time and has a cactus and other plants shop.
Read More »

Copycat chocolate wars

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 May 2018

Waitrose is facing fresh allegations of chocolate plagiarism as Hotel Chocolat claim the superstore has launched a range of bars which it claims bear an uncanny resemblance to their own.
Read More »

Defamation, Corbyn and Mohammed Kozbar

Written by Michael Coyle on 10 May 2018

It was reported this week that the Sunday Telegraph paid “substantial damages” to the general secretary of Finsbury Park mosque after the paper had falsely portrayed Mr Kozbar as a supporter of a violent lslamist extremist. Its end game apparently was not only to smear Mr Kozbar but to link him to the Labour leader, Jeremy Corbyn.
Read More »

Sir Cliff Richard v BBC

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 13 April 2018

Whilst Sir Cliff was not charged with any offences, he is now suing the BBC on the basis that the raid caused “profound and long-lasting damage”.
Read More »

Serious harm in the Supreme Court

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 06 April 2018

Independent Print Ltd, the unsuccessful defendant in the case of Lachaux v Independent Print Ltd [2017] EWCA Civ 1327 has been granted permission to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision and subsequent application of Section 1(1) of the Defamation Act 2013
Read More »

Stupid Patent of the Month

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 01 December 2017

With patents ranging from a “scan to email” and “bilateral and multilateral decision making” it does make for an interesting read. However, when US Patent Number, 6,690,400 was featured, things took a down turn.
Read More »

Peppa Pig wins piggie fight

Written by Michael Coyle on 01 October 2017

Pippa Pig and Tobbias went head to head this week and thankfully Peppa Pig came out on top! The EUIPO first found in favour of Tobbias bu the EUIPO First Board of Appeal (R1776/2016-1) gave a different response and annulled the decision for all its goods. It highlights amongst other things the opposition lottery that is the EUIPO.
Read More »

Game of Thrones pirates arrested in India

Written by Jessie Hamill-Stewart on 15 August 2017

It should be no surprise to fans of Game of Thrones, the most pirated TV show in history, that a recent episode was leaked a few days prior to its official release.
Read More »

Time for a switch?

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 August 2017

The Nintendo Switch has taken the gaming world by storm and is by far the best-selling console this year. However as one would now expect along with success comes the lawsuits!
Read More »

Employment Tribunal fees unlawful: success for Unison

Written by Ellis Sweetenham on 28 July 2017

After a lack of success in the High Court and the Court of Appeal, trade union Unison have succeeded in their battle for justice after the UK Supreme Court has rules that the fees for the employment tribunal are unlawful.
Read More »

IP and General Civil Restraint Orders

Written by Thomas Mould on 16 May 2017

A Civil Restraint Order restricts the subject of the Order - usually a claimant who continues to bring vexatious claims from bringing further claims in the future without the permission of the court.
Read More »

Exclusion Clause Fails

Written by Mark Reed on 17 March 2017

Impact Funding Solutions Ltd took action against a firm of Solicitors over claims that the solicitors were obliged to indemnify them after they went into liquidation, even though an exclusion clause within the terms agreed with the indemnity insurers stated they could not recover losses as a third party.
Read More »

Twitter is not the wild west

Written by Michael Coyle on 11 March 2017

Katie Hopkins was left counting the cost of two tweets £16,000 and £8000 respectively, after she yesterday lost a defamation case...but if you live by the sword....
Read More »

Who are you? Tartan army loses dispute

Written by Michael Coyle on 27 February 2017

The owner of the “Tartan Army” trade marks failed this month to prevent a third party using the name without its permission. https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/search-judgments/judgment?id=3e6b2aa7-8980-69d2-b500-ff0000d74aa7
Read More »

Employment Law case: Court of Appeal decides a self-employed person in fact has ‘worker’ status.

Written by By Mark Reed on 21 February 2017

Mr Smith worked as a self-employed operative for over 6 years for Pimlico Plumbers, with an understanding from both parties that he was an independent contractor who owned his own business and used his own tools, but with a specific arrangement with PPL. After a heart attack, Smith took action against Pimlico for wrongful dismissal. The Court of Appeal deemed his employment status a 'worker'.
Read More »

Royal butler succeeds in action against misuse of private information.

Written by Mark Reed on 04 February 2017

The claimant was a butler for the royal family and worked under them for over 21 years. In 2002, various meetings took place between the claimant and the defendant, a prominent and successful public relations consultant. Throughout these meetings, the claimant sent a letter to the defendant with information of his relationship with the royals, and specifically the Queen and the Duke of Edinburgh. This letter was then faxed through to a newspaper, and although it wasn’t published, the claimant sought action for breach of confidence and the misuse of private information.
Read More »

Tomlin orders- what do I need to know?

Written by Ellis Sweetenham on 18 January 2017

When considering taking a matter to court, IP or otherwise, it can seem quite daunting. A main part of this is the jargon and confusing words and phrases that are only used in legal land.
Read More »

Brexit in the Supreme Court

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 06 December 2016

Ten men and one woman decide whether parliament or the government has the authority to trigger Brexit in a historic legal challenge.
Read More »


Written by Michael Coyle on 24 November 2016

It was reported last month that a Coventry nightclub received a cease and desist letter from Trump's people regarding use of his image....
Read More »

Common Design in IP

Written by Michael Coyle on 21 October 2016

Too often in IP litigation the successful party wins its case and seeks to enforce the Judgement against the losing party only to be told the losing party is now in administration. Well in IP you must consider Common Design as a way of protecting your position in the event that you do win ie join in the director!
Read More »

Brexit legality in the Royal Court of Justice

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 13 October 2016

Today, 13 October 2016, three of the most senior Judges in England and Wales namely, the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, newly appointed master of the rolls, Sir Terence Etherton, and Lord Justice Sales will hear arguments from both sides of Brexit in the Royal Courts of Justice.
Read More »

Norwich Pharmacal - how did it get its name?

Written by Michael Coyle on 24 September 2016

It was back in 1974 where the heavyweights of the Appeal Court heard a case entitled NORWICH PHARMACAL CO. AND OTHERS APPELLANTS AND CUSTOMS AND EXCISE COMMISSIONERS RESPONDENTS
Read More »

ECJ limits confusion to German-speaking member states only

Written by Michael Coyle on 23 September 2016

The ECJ provided an order and guidance on the position where a sign which was only found to give rise to likelihood of confusion with an EU trade mark in non-English speaking EU member states. (combit Software GmbH v Commit Business Solutions Ltd, Case C-223/15, 22 September 2016.)
Read More »

MasterCard is being sued for £14bn

Written by Samuel O'Toole on 12 September 2016

MasterCard is being sued for £14bn, following allegations that it has overcharged 46m UK customers, in what is set to make British history as the largest legal claim.
Read More »

ECJ rules of Hyperlinking

Written by Thomas Mould on 12 September 2016

Online publishers who knowingly link to illegally uploaded content are liable for copyright infringement, according to the European Court of Justice.
Read More »

Sky comes out on top...

Written by Michael Coyle on 09 June 2016

The Intellectual Property Enterprise Court ('IPEC') dismissed an application for a declaration that "Skyscape" in relation to certain IT-related services did not infringe Sky's trade marks. This is excellent news for Sky and bad news for anyone wanting to use SKY as a brand or company name.
Read More »

The dying embers of the Fag trade

Written by Michael Coyle on 28 May 2016

The UK was cleared this week to make plain packaging compulsory on cigarettes, after the High Court rejected a legal challenge brought by the world's top four tobacco companies, Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco, Japan Tobacco International and Imperial Brands.
Read More »

Injunction to remain

Written by Michael Coyle on 21 April 2016

The supreme court today has reserved its decision on whether or not to lift a temporary privacy injunction preventing identification of a celebrity and a sex story.
Read More »

Stairway to a legal claim

Written by Michael Coyle on 17 April 2016

Is Led Zep's famous ditty 'Stairway to Heaven' an original piece of work or has it been copied? We will soon find out...
Read More »

We can stop these trolls but only together

Written by Michael Coyle on 27 March 2016

The endless attacks from TCYK and Goldeneye continue in the last few days we have seen hundreds more people contacting Lawdit having received a nonsense letter from both aggressors. Is there anything we can do?
Read More »

Pushing legal boundaries....almost... 8 second clips and Copyright

Written by Michael Coyle on 22 March 2016

The Claimants were the owners of the copyrights in television broadcasts, and in films incorporated within broadcasts, of most cricket matches played by the England men's and women's cricket teams in England and Wales. The Defendants operated a website which showed 8 second clips like Vine. But could they? Was it an infringement of copyright or fair dealing for the purposes of reporting current events and secondarily upon immunities for acting as a mere conduit and hosting.
Read More »

I'm the only Kylie Kylie Kylie Kyie

Written by Michael Coyle on 05 March 2016

This is the story of two Kylies...one Kylie Minogue of Neighbours, "I could be so lucky" etc etc and the other Kylie is Kylie Janner- who she? Apparently she is Kylie Kristen Jenner an American reality television personality, socialite and model. Can Kylie M stop Kylie J Go Kylie M
Read More »

Taxi drivers lose again in court!

Written by Michael Coyle on 22 January 2016

After Uber, London taxi drivers lost again. This time for a claim for trade mark infringement and passing off. The Claimant London Taxi Corporation is the manufacturer of the well known London taxi and various similar models. Frazer-Nash Research Limited and Ecotive Limited ( The Defendants) manufactured a similar taxi Metrocab. The Claim concerns the shape of the Defendants' taxi, which it contends has been substantially copied from the shape of their taxi yet it advanced no claim for infringement of any registered design, design right or copyright. Instead it claims infringement of its Trade Marks on three alternative bases as well as passing off.
Read More »

The comments by Mr Justice Smith against Sports Direct

Written by Michael Coyle on 22 January 2016

The dispute concerned a Confidentiality Undertaking dated 5th September 2014 given to Mike Ashley's Sports Direct Group and relates to Glasgow Rangers. His Lordship was not to impressed with the actions of Mr Ashley's company. http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Ch/2016/85.html
Read More »

UK IPO scammer found liable

Written by Ellis Sweetenham on 11 November 2015

A record fine has been issued in a case relating to the scamming of UK Intellectual Property Office customers.
Read More »

How to run the perfect scam and make a million +++

Written by Michael Coyle on 11 November 2015

Some of you may have received a reminder to pay renewal fees by what appears to be legitimate official looking correspondence from the UKIPO. Its a scam by Mr Jonasson who resides in Stockholm. Jonasson received a total of £1,334,234 from trade mark holders. What a complete rat.
Read More »

IPEC and bringing a claim in the IP court

Written by Michael Coyle on 10 November 2015

I have an IP dispute. Where shall I bring my case? Its probable that your claim will be best aired via the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court ('IPEC') especially if you’re involved in a dispute that concerns copyrights, patents, registered designs and trade marks, designs and confidentiality.
Read More »

Bastian Schweinsteiger is NOT a nazi

Written by Michael Coyle on 23 October 2015

Bastian Schweinsteiger the MUFC midfield maestro is considering legal action as a result of a Nazi doll which apparently resembles him See for yourself http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-34606799
Read More »

Lawyers off the hook?

Written by Michael Coyle on 21 October 2015

A draft bill published by the Law Commission may well eliminate the risk of lawyers being personally sued for "making threats" when pursuing breaches of intellectual property (IP) rights.
Read More »

Isle of Wight man defeats council - win win for parents

Written by Michael Coyle on 17 October 2015

An Isle of Wight man who took his daughter on holiday during term time was successful in his attempts at overturning a court fine after arguing that her unauthorised absence did not mean she failed to attend school regularly.
Read More »

Apple in New Patent Trouble

Written by Thomas Mould on 15 October 2015

Apple is in further patent trouble this week. A Jury in the US has found that it has used a patent owned by the University of Wisconsin in its IPhones and IPads without permission.
Read More »

No injunctive relief for copycat packaging

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 October 2015

The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills and Intellectual Property Office have ruled against allowing businesses an enforcement power to seek civil injunctions against copycat packaging.
Read More »

Justified threats in IP law- clarification as last?

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 October 2015

A Law Commission published a report today alongside the draft Intellectual Property (Unjustified Threats) Bill that would implement reforms the Commission recommended in 2014. If enacted, the Bill will:bring the law for trade marks and designs into line with that for patents; and provide a much clearer framework within which businesses and their professional advisers can operate to resolve disputes.
Read More »

Hoverboards illegal since 1835

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 October 2015

If you are hoping to jump on your hoverboard today forget it. Riding hoverboards on the pavement is banned under Section 72 of the Highway Act 1835 in England and Wales.
Read More »

Dismissed Blinkbox employees fight back

Written by Ellis Sweetenham on 13 October 2015

The Company who owned defunct Blinkbox, a music service supplied by Tesco, is being faced with a £10 million class action lawsuit after 80 former employees claim their redundancy payments were not satisfied.
Read More »

I'm ( supposed to be) leaving on a Jet plane....

Written by Michael Coyle on 19 September 2015

I'm ( supposed to be) leaving on a Jet plane....( John Denver (ish) The European Court of Justice (ECJ) yesterday reached a final decision on your ability to obtain compensation in respect of travel delays. In Van der Lans v Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij NV (C-257/14) the ECJ has given tens of thousands of airline passengers entitlement to claim up to GBP 438 compensation for flight delays. There are millions at stake..
Read More »

Consumer laws a brief guide

Written by Ethan Turner on 05 September 2015

Consumer Act 2015 By Ethan Turner Year 11 student at Thornden High School The Act is split into three parts. Part 1: Consumer contracts for goods. Part 2: Covers unfair terms. Part 3: Contains miscellaneous and general provisions.
Read More »

Expert evidence

Written by Michael Coyle on 30 August 2015

Mr Justice Warren in British Airways PLC and Paul Spencer and 11 others partly upheld an appeal against a deputy master's initial refusal to permit BA to introduce expert evidence.
Read More »

Is the Intellectual Property Court working?

Written by Michael Coyle on 05 August 2015

An independent report on the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court I IPEC) as commissioned by the Intellectual Property Office has concluded that the reforms introduced in 2010 are having a positive effect on sme's thirst for justice.
Read More »

Forget the Garrick what about Isle of Wight bingo?

Written by Michael Coyle on 08 July 2015

Most people don't give a toot about London’s private and male-only Garrick Club but it made the headlines this week when it voted to continue the ban on women attending the club. Well the Isle of Wight's bingo crowd was already banning men and voted to continue the ban this May.
Read More »

Consumer protection and consumer rights

Written by Michael Coyle on 07 July 2015

The Consumer Rights Act is due to come in to force by 1 October 2015. After the Competition and Market's Authority ('CMA') reported we are all paying far too much for our energy bills, will the CRA come to Using unfair contractual terms or notices can have a number of consequences for your business. Most importantly, they will not be binding on a consumer. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), Trading Standards and other regulatory bodies might apply for an injunction to prevent you from using a term in your T&Cs, even if no complaint has been received. Alternatively, a regulatory body might request an undertaking from you that the term will no longer be used. This poses a reputational risk for traders, as, in both instances, the CMA will publish details of any application for an injunction or undertaking that is accepted. consumer's rescue?
Read More »

Trip Advisor, bad reviews and dont believe what you read!

Written by Michael Coyle on 05 July 2015

Trip Advisor, bad reviews and don't believe what you read! A few years ago the Advertising Standards Authority ('ASA') ruled that TripAdvisor's claim their reviews were genuine were infact misleading because the origin of the reviews could not be substantiated https://www.asa.org.uk/ASA-action/Adjudications/2012/2/TripAdvisor-LLC/SHP_ADJ_166867.aspx This position was was further highlighted in today's Independent on Sunday's story which highlights the absurd nature of the review business.
Read More »

A victory for religion?

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 June 2015

Religion or belief and sexual orientation are protected characteristics under section 4 of the Equality Act 2010 (EqA 2010). But what happens when these protected characteristcs clash with say homosexuality. The Tribunal discussed these issues in Mbuyi v Newpark Childcare (Shepherds Bush) Ltd ET/3300656/14, 4 June 2015.
Read More »

ICANN releases .sucks

Written by Thomas Mould on 01 June 2015

The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) will roll out the .sucks domain name from June 1
Read More »

DC Comics v Rihanna

Written by Thomas Mould on 01 June 2015

Rihanna has filed a trade mark for 'Robyn' which is her real name. DC aren't happy with this due to the similarity to Robin: the boy wonder a trade mark they have owned since 1984.
Read More »

SMART WATER revoked for Non-Use

Written by Thomas Mould on 13 May 2015

The EU General Court has held that test sales amounting to €800 were not enough to demonstrate genuine use of the SMART WATER Community trade mark (CTM) for drinks
Read More »

Erection news

Written by Michael Coyle on 09 May 2015

The Electoral Commissioner has an abundance of rules when it comes to voting. http://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/i-am-a/electoral-administrator but what about a penis?
Read More »

Bye Bye Skype

Written by Michael Coyle on 06 May 2015

The Court of Justice of the European Union today ruled in favour of Sky in Cases T-423/12, T-183/13 and T-184/13 Skype Ultd v OHIM. In short Sky has won its case and Skype will have to change its name..lets hope Skype appeals as its a silly decision.
Read More »

Common design in IP cases

Written by Michael Coyle on 28 April 2015

Can someone be held liable if he is employed through a company for intellectual property infringment? The short answer is yes.
Read More »

Passing Off- An Overview

Written by Thomas Mould on 24 April 2015

In this article it will explain the basic criteria you will need to show in order to succeed in a claim for Passing Off.
Read More »

When you cannot hide behind a company

Written by Michael Coyle on 16 April 2015

You are clear in your own mind that there has been an infringement of your intellectual property. For the sake of argument lets say Copyright. Your lawyers say “SUE SUE SUE, FOR GODS SAKE SUE”!
Read More »

Speculative invoicing or protecting your ipr?

Written by Michael Coyle on 07 March 2015

A legitimate cause of action or speculative invoicing? There are infringements online. Many.Its wrong. It follows that copyright owners have a legitimate interest in obtaining legal remedies to stop such infringements for example by issuing a claim in the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court ( IPEC) or via IPEC's small claims court. But when does the right to enforce your intellectual property rights cross over to become speculative invoicing?
Read More »

Supreme. A monopoly too far when it comes to pet food

Written by Michael Coyle on 07 March 2015

The High Court last week dismissed an action for trade mark infringement brought by the owner of five UK and Community trade marks featuring the word "supreme" against a competitior. (Supreme Petfoods Ltd v Henry Bell & Co (Grantham) Ltd [2015] EWHC 256 (Ch), 12 February 2015.) The case dragged on for days, cost a small fortune and one wondered why? http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Ch/2015/256.html
Read More »

Hall & Oates only in America

Written by Michael Coyle on 07 March 2015

Hall and Oates the US musical twosome ( young people take note they were famous in 80s) are suing a Brooklyn-based cereal firm, claiming its granola Haulin' Oats infringes their trade mark.
Read More »

Playboy takes on Playboy

Written by Michael Coyle on 21 February 2015

Michael Ross is currently suing Playboy according to Bloomberg http://www.bloomberg.com/topics/intellectual-property. The dispute concerns Mr Ross's use of playboy.london.
Read More »

Unregistered Rights - where to sue

Written by Michael Coyle on 23 January 2015

Horrible problem for anyone - where to sue? Especially when an unregistered right like copyright has been allegedly infringed online, where and what court has jurisdiction to decide the resulting case?
Read More »

Private Landlords Beware

Written by Rehana Ali on 23 January 2015

Since April 2007, landlords have been under an obligation to protect deposits paid under an assured shorthold tenancy, a recent decision by the Court of Appeal indicates that this rule may now even apply before the scheme even started?
Read More »

Rihanna wins appeal against Topshop

Written by Michael Coyle on 22 January 2015

Rihanna, the world famous pop star, wins appeal about the sale of fashion garments by Topshop bearing her image. Background During one of Rihanna’s photoshoots to promote her "Talk That Talk" a photographer ( the owner of the work) took a photo and licensed it to Topshop. In 2012 Topshop began to sell in its stores and through its website a fashion t-shirt with the image of Rihanna.
Read More »

ADR and Litigation

Written by Rehana Ali on 13 January 2015

The following article takes a fleeting look at some of the types of ADR available to parties as alternatives to litigation.
Read More »

Summary Judgment - A guide

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 December 2014

How To Obtain A Summary Judgment For Money Claims A civil dispute can be time-consuming and expensive. One way to bypass the whole process is to issue an application for summary judgment, if granted, it enables you to obtain Judgment at an early stage.
Read More »

Google Fed Up

Written by Daniel Selby on 11 December 2014

Google closes their news site in Spain after a change in intellectual property law.
Read More »

Damages- What can I claim?

Written by Mekael Rahman on 30 November 2014

Damages - What Can I Claim? When one or more contracting parties are in breach of a contract/ agreement, an award of damages (the principal remedy in English law) is generally granted to the adversely affected entity.
Read More »

Allocation and Part 26 CPR 1998

Written by Rehana Ali on 28 November 2014

The following articles look into the process of allocation and the use of allocation questionnaires in litigation as prescribed by the Civil Procedure Rules 1998. Part 1 is a general introduction to the process of allocation and part 2 looks in depth at the contents of an allocation questionnaire.
Read More »

Ford denied trade mark protection in Russia

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 November 2014

Ford Motor Company has lost its case against Federal Service for Intellectual Property, Patents and trademarks (Rospatent). A recent Court ruling has denied trade mark protection for its iconic blue oval logo with the word 'Ford'.
Read More »

Urine and litigation news

Written by Michael Coyle on 19 September 2014

Goalkeeper threatens to sue the fans having drinking from his water bottle only to discover its was their urine..ugh...talk about fans taking the..........
Read More »

Deadmau5 takes the Mickey

Written by Thomas Mould on 18 September 2014

Deadmau5, the famous DJ known for his use of a mouse mask on stage sought to protect his trade mark image but got more than he bargained for.
Read More »

No heading please- its dangerous

Written by Michael Coyle on 30 August 2014

In what will be a significant blow for Marouane Fellaini a claim has been issued by a group of individuals in the USA against FIFA. The claim is founded on the risks of heading a football.
Read More »

Zara shoots the sherrif!

Written by Michael Coyle on 28 August 2014

The importance of doing clearance searches on all aspects of IP was highlighted yesterday as the well known high street retailer Zara launched what it thought was a cool and trendy top - 'western' style, only to be faced with a barrage of criticism for the shirt's resemblance to the shirts worn by those in concentration camps during the Holocaust.
Read More »

Costs. Loser pays legal costs

Written by Michael Coyle on 10 August 2014

Loser pays the other side’s costs Its fairly obvious but just in case you did not know under English law the basic principle is the loser pays the winner's legal costs. Often this means a contribution only.....
Read More »

No Lien Over Data

Written by Muhammed Poswall on 08 August 2014

The article discusses whether a lien can be placed over data in light of the decision in Your Response Ltd v Datateam Business Media Ltd.
Read More »

Jaw Jaw...not war war!

Written by Michael Coyle on 05 July 2014

If you do enter in to a dispute always talk talk and talk, its better than war war war! Nothing surprises us anymore but a recent case highlighted how important it is that the parties in a dispute continue to talk. The case was Bristol Groundschool Limited as the Claimant against Intelligent Data Capture as the Defendant http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Ch/2014/2145.html
Read More »

Implied terms, claim fails on two counts

Written by Michael Coyle on 28 June 2014

The Intellectual Property Enterprise Court dismissed an action for passing off and breach of contract by the claimant Orvec a company which traded in textile products aimed at airlines for use by their passengers. You know... pillows, blankets, headrest covers, tray mats and towels.......Orvec’s opponent was an advertising agency.
Read More »

Wonga shows its true colours

Written by Michael Coyle on 25 June 2014

It was heavily reported today that Wonga has been ordered to pay more than £2.6m compensation after it was found to have sent threatening letters to customers from non-existent law firms! The Financial Conduct Authority ('FCA') said Wonga was guilty of "unfair and misleading debt collection practices".
Read More »


Written by Michael Coyle on 21 June 2014

The increasingly brilliant website WordPress has called time on those copyright holders who seek to abuse US Copyright laws and use lawyers to censor perfectly legal content. Most requests are legitimate, but it is seeking to prevent those abusive takedown notices which take up a lot of the company’s time and resources.
Read More »

WIPO and Domains

Written by Michael Coyle on 15 June 2014

Filing a complaint against a domain name holder with WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Centre We seem to be getting more and more domain name complaints. The main reason is cyber squatting. Another regular occurrence of domain name disputes arises where IT providers register a client’s domain name in order to fulfil their required services. Where there is a breakdown of relations the IT provider is often left as the registered owner of their client’s domain name.
Read More »

The Claimant has no money but he is suing me HELP!

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 June 2014

It is a familiar problem. The Defendant is confident of their defence, but fearful about the prospect of recovering costs from the claimant, should his claim fail. That is the Claimant will simply wind his company up and call it a day. One option may be to consider Security for Costs.
Read More »

eBay data breach; now its getting serious

Written by Rehana Ali on 24 May 2014

Action against ebay hots up The UK's information commissioner has stated that it is working with European data authorities with a view to taking action against eBay's recent data breach. It is claimed that some 145 million users have been affected. Everyone at Lawdit affected too and we have all changed our data information.
Read More »

Getting it right from the outset

Written by Michael Coyle on 22 May 2014

It is so important that clients understand the importance of carrying out a full review before a claim is issued or applications issued. The claim is important and a client who is too eager to commence a claim or see justice done can often backfire in a big way. This was highlighted this week in Case: Parkway Construction Ltd (In Liquidation) v Howard De Walden Estates Ltd [2014] EWHC 1533 (TCC) (15 May 2014).
Read More »

Mitchell – Is the tide turning?

Written by Muhammed Poswall on 09 May 2014

The article looks at the decision in Mitchell v News Group Newspapers and provides a look at the approach the courts have taken since that decision.
Read More »

UK aims to stop copycat packaging

Written by Michael Coyle on 26 April 2014

The British government has called for evidence on whether to give to businesses a new civil injunctive power to stop copycat packaging, under the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 (SI 2008/1277) (CPUT).
Read More »

Getty, Copyright and settlement

Written by Michael Coyle on 15 April 2014

Getty Images is the worldwide renowned image database which offers for by way of license millions of images for sale. So what happens if you receive a letter from Getty/debt collectors/solicitors threatening you with a claim? ....Well read on............
Read More »

Preparing a Bundle for Court

Written by Michael Coyle on 30 March 2014

Going to Court can be a daunting matter and there are many things that have to be sorted before the trial. One of the most important is the bundle, this contains all the documents relating to the case which gives the Judge a proper view of the case and access to the documents that are to be relied upon. A Bad bundle will result in a lost case. A good bundle will often result in a positive outcome and a happy Judge. Always keep the Judge happy!
Read More »

Employment Tribunals and CPR Rules on Witness Statements

Written by Rehana Ali on 28 March 2014

A witness statement created for the purpose of a hearing must deal with all the issues an Employment Tribunal must consider in relation to a parties claim. The following article details the required form and content of a witness statement according to the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR).
Read More »

New EU powers to seize counterfeit goods

Written by Michael Coyle on 26 March 2014

New laws have been approved by the European Parliament to extend national authorities powers within the European Union (EU) to seize and confiscate counterfeit goods travelling through Europe even if they are destined for a non-EU country.
Read More »

Pothole law-grrrrrrr

Written by Michael Coyle on 08 March 2014

Every council ought to have a reasonable system in place to ensure that they regularly inspect roads and repair them if necessary. So the first point of call is to enquire if they have the above in place. You do this by making a freedom of information request. Then what? Read on.................
Read More »

Arsenal v Reed - Back on?

Written by Michael Coyle on 01 March 2014

Mathew Reed used to sell unofficial Arsenal goods outside of the then Highbury Stadium. Arsenal filed a claim claiming that Reed was selling its trade marks and intellectual property without a licence and therefore was trade mark infringement.
Read More »

How we get paid- Costs!

Written by Michael Coyle on 01 March 2014

In litigation the general rule is the loser pays the winner costs. Costs means legal costs. So what you pay your legal team in solicitor's, barristers and other expenses ie experts, surveys, etc. Where the claim is for more than £10,000 then we get paid once the case is won and costs are assessed by a court but how do they come to a final figure?....read on....
Read More »

Discovery and the need to diclose

Written by MichaeL Coyle on 01 March 2014

A key part to any litigation is Disclosure and Disclosure reports. The arguments cropped up this week when disclosure reports were discussed at the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court. Here the Defendant refused to disclose reports.
Read More »

Witness Statements

Written by Muhammed Poswall on 14 February 2014

The article discusses the importance of witness statements and when they are needed in litigation.
Read More »

Security for costs

Written by Aasim Durrani on 07 February 2014

An overview of the court's considerations when deciding whether to make an order for security of costs.
Read More »

Unfair Dismissal - The Basics

Written by Michael Coyle on 24 January 2014

A key part to any business is the relationship between employer and employer. Often the issue of unfair dismissal crops up. Let's take a look.
Read More »

Dispute and the CPR

Written by Michael Coyle on 08 December 2013

The rules that govern civil litigation in England and Wales can be found in the the Civil Procedure Rules (‘CPR’). The CPR applies equally in the county court as in the High Court. Prior to the CPR we had to deal with the white book and the green book for the High and County Court respectively- which was horrid.
Read More »

Patents and Damages

Written by Michael Coyle on 08 December 2013

You've won the case, yippeee! Now the problems really start! So finally, after three years of your life, £50,000 in fees and god knows how much weight and hair loss, the Judge agreed that your patent has been infringed. You party all night long only to be told that now you have to have damages assessed and that your problems are not yet over. The key question is how do you assess damages and will you ever see any money? Its your job after all to prove loss not the Defendant's.
Read More »

Passing off. Goodwill in a place of business

Written by Michael Coyle on 23 November 2013

The principles of the law of passing off can be summed up as follows:- (1) that the claimant's goods or services have acquired a goodwill or reputation in the market and are known by some distinguishing feature; (2) that there is a misrepresentation by the defendant (whether or not intentional) leading or likely to lead the public to believe that goods or services offered by the defendant are goods or services of the claimant; and (3) that the plaintiff has suffered to is likely to suffer damage as a result of the erroneous belief engendered by the defendant's misrepresentation. But how does this apply to a place of business?
Read More »

Challenging a company name

Written by Michael Coyle on 23 November 2013

When I was at Law School the Act of Parliament that any aspiring commercial lawyer would be required to know was the Companies 1985. This was replaced by the Companies Act 2006 (the 2006 Act) which replaced the company law provisions of the Companies Act 1985. An important part of the 2006 Act introduced sections 69 to 74 ie objections to company names. There soon followed the Company Names Adjudicator Rules 2008 which came into effect on 1 October 2008.
Read More »

What is a reasonable notice period?

Written by Michael Coyle on 16 November 2013

A case that was originally about passing off turned in to a contractual dispute over what was deemed to be reasonable notice in a supply contract. Hamsard 3147 Ltd (t/a Mini Mode Childrenswear) v Boots UK Ltd [2013] EWHC 3251 (Ch), 31 October 2013, Norris J. The claim was mainly concerned with the termination of an agreement between Boots and its former childrenswear supplier, Hamsard 3147 Ltd ('Hamsard'). The latter sought damages for wrongful termination of the supply contract. The Judge identified four key points but the main issue was whether 9 months' notice to terminate the contract was a reasonable period or was it too short?
Read More »

Court fees, what you would expect to pay

Written by Michael Coyle on 16 November 2013

Putting aside your legal fees - (depending on the solicitor and location you will pay anywhere from £150-600 per hour), you will also need to budget for court fees.
Read More »

Dyson and Samsung litigate

Written by Michael Coyle on 20 October 2013

Dyson the iconic British brand have commenced legal action in the English High Court against Korean giant Samsung over the alleged infringement of Dyon's patents and designs. Dyson is well know for protecting its IPR. in the past 20 years Dyson has spent vast amounts of money in filing and securing its portfolio and also in protecting its intellectual property by litigation. At present Dyson are involved in 13 legal battles. This is not the first time that Dyson have issued legal proceedings against Samsung, In 2009 Dyson successfully sued Samsung for trying to patent its “triple-cyclone”patent, as a result Samsung were forced to pay Dyson £600,000.
Read More »

A dispute in a letter. Scrabble letter

Written by Michael Coyle on 20 October 2013

Mattel the owner of Scrabble has accused Zynga of infringing four trade marks. This article focuses on one of the four alleged infringements. The trade mark in question (UK no. 2154349) is described as “a 3d ivory-coloured tile with a letter of the Roman alphabet and a number from one to ten on the top”. This trade mark was registered in three classes one of which was under class 9 for computer game adaptations of board games.
Read More »

Jaw Jaw better than War War

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 October 2013

Jaw Jaw not War War. Make a Part 36 offer! Entering discussions with a view to settling the dispute is always a good idea. You of course will have to compromise but its better than losing everything if the case goes against you. Remember loser pays winner and its a brutal business. This article looks how you do this. Its all contained in the CPR and Part 36.
Read More »

Ryanair Defamation Dispute with Daily Mail Settled

Written by Rehana Ali on 13 September 2013

The budget airline Ryanair has been pursuing claims for defamation against a number of organisations for defamatory comments including Channel 4, the Daily Mirror and The Independent newspapers, in particular Ryanair recently sued the Daily Mail newspaper for an article that suggested pilots employed by Ryanair had raised concerns that the airlines fuel policy may have been putting passengers at risk.
Read More »

Rihanna v Topshop

Written by Harmeet Singh, a work experience student at Lawdit Solicitors on 22 August 2013

A brief note on the recent case of Rihanna v Topshop.
Read More »

Electronic Disclosure - Multi-Track

Written by Michael Coyle on 08 August 2013

This article discusses electronic disclosure and Practice Direction 31B in Multi-Track claims and the requirements of the parties since the Jackson reforms.
Read More »

Rihanna and Top Shop fight over use of her image name

Written by Michael Coyle on 31 July 2013

Topshop the well known fashion retailer lost a High Court claim this week to Rihanna the famous pop star. In March 2012 Topshop sold a t-shirt with an image of Rihanna on it. The image was a photograph taken by an independent photographer. Topshop had a licence from the photographer but no licence from Rihanna. Rihanna contended that the sale of this t-shirt without her permission infringed her rights. Topshop disagreed. A court case ensued. The Judge made clear that there is no such law in the UK for "image rights" however the media wishes to sell this. The case concerned passing off. Unsurprisingly Rihanna won. Damages to be assessed at a later stage.
Read More »

Pre-Action Conduct

24 July 2013

This article discusses the history of pre-action conduct/protocols, practice directions for pre-action conduct, complience and preaction correspondence.
Read More »

Case Management

Written by Michael Coyle on 19 July 2013

This article discusses the principles a court will take into account when deciding where to allocate a claim. The multi-track, the fast-track and the small claims track.
Read More »

Without Notice Applications (formally Ex parte Application)

Written by Michael Coyle on 23 June 2013

The general idea, is that an Order should not be made against a party without that party being given an opportunity to be heard. However, it is possible to make an Application without notice to the Respondent. This article discusses that option.
Read More »

Issuing a Part 8 Claim

Written by Michael Coyle on 17 June 2013

This article discusses how to issue and a Part 8 Claim, fees, acknowledge service, evidence in opposition, time frames, evidence, allocation etc.
Read More »

Default Judgments (General Overview)

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 June 2013

This article discusses Default Judgments and explains how they are not determined by a trial but are an administrative process. The article discusses how a Claimant can file for a Default Judgment of an Acknowledgement of Service and Defence; how to make the Application; what the application can be for; when a Claimant cannot file for a Judgment in Default and more.
Read More »

Trade mark infringement damages – the 'user principle' (finally!)

Written by Michael Coyle on 07 June 2013

This article discusses the ‘user principle’ which is typically used in patent cases to work out damages. Very often the problem in trade mark infringement cases is trying to determine damages. so being able to apply the user principle makes the assessment of damages simplier. In the recent case of 32Red -v- William Hill, the Court the Judge implemented the user principle when assessing damages in trade mark saying that the principle should be based on ‘objective’ factors and should not be based on the ‘specific characteristics and circumstances’ of the parties to the claim.
Read More »

Personal Injury - Schedule of Loss

Written by Michael Coyle on 03 June 2013

This article discusses the schedule of the financial losses known as a Schedule of Loss incurred by a party in a personal injury case and the heading and sub heading within.
Read More »

Sale of faulty goods to a consumer - Remedies

Written by Michael Coyle on 28 May 2013

This article discusses consumer rights, reasonable time for examining goods purchased, options available to consumers in different circumstances. Currently, where the goods purchased are less than 6 months old it is presumed that the goods were faulty at the time of purchase and the consumer can reject goods by returning the goods for a full refundand can sue for damages for other foreseeable losses due to the faulty goods.
Read More »

Issuing a Claim in the Patents County Court

Written by Michael Coyle on 24 May 2013

This article discusses where to issue a Claim in the Patents County Court, the procedure for issuing a claim including the Practice Direction on Pre-action Conduct, service of documents, the rules on time limits for filing a Defence and/or Reply and the requirement to comply with paragraph 7.1(1) and Annex A (paragraph 2) of the Practice Direction (Pre-Action Conduct).
Read More »

Issuing a Claim at IPEC

Written by Michael Coyle on 24 May 2013

This article discusses where to issue a Claim in the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court, the procedure for issuing a claim including the Practice Direction on Pre-action Conduct, service of documents, the rules on time limits for filing a Defence and/or Reply and the requirement to comply with paragraph 7.1(1) and Annex A (paragraph 2) of the Practice Direction (Pre-Action Conduct).
Read More »

Jurisdiction: An Overview

Written by Aneela Akbar on 20 May 2013

An overview of jurisdiction and the two rules determining whether or not the English courts have jurisdiction to resolve a dispute.
Read More »

Part 20 additional claims against a third party.

Written by Michael Coyle on 18 May 2013

This article is about Part 20 additional claims against a third party and discusses the filing of a Part 20 Defence where permission from the Court is required, service of the claim, time limits etc.
Read More »

Motorola v Apple

Written by Rehana Ali on 07 May 2013

Motorola Mobility as owned by Google is reported to have abused its position in the German Mobile market following the filing of a patent injunction against Apple
Read More »

ADR Disadvantages

Written by Michael J Coyle on 16 February 2013

As a general principle, no one can be forced to resolve a dispute by any form of ADR, such as mediation and conciliation, against their wishes. If a party suggests ADR to resolve their problems, the other party does not have to agree and most ADR procedures allow any party to withdraw at any stage prior to a solution is agreed. There are several disadvantages to dispute resolution, which often affects both parties sentiment to settle. So lets take a look!
Read More »

SRA publishes press release

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 September 2011

An email today from the SRA entitled "Davenport Lyons: Greed clouds judgement and results in 20K fine", pretty much sums up how many of the hundreds of clients we acted for felt.
Read More »

Space Airconditioning Plc -v- (1) Mr Guy; and (2) Smith Brothers Stores Limited

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 08 August 2011

In May 2011 the High Court heard Space Airconditioning Plc's case against (1) Mr Adrian Guy; and (2) Smith Brothers Stores Limited in a claim that alleged extraction, retention and use of confidential information by the first defendant, Mr Adrian Guy, and alleged inducement by the second defendant, Smith Brothers Stores Limited of confidential information.
Read More »

ASA Rule Against TalkTalk

Written by Ben Evans on 22 July 2011

The Advertsing Standards Agency (ASA) have decided that a TV advert for telecoms company TalkTalk was misleading and cannot be shown again.
Read More »

Hackers and Hacking

Written by Michael Coyle on 08 July 2011

A look at the laws surrounding the RIPA and the DPA. News International in big big trouble.
Read More »

Rio seeks privacy

04 July 2011

Rio Ferdinand has requested Justice Nicol prevent further details of his private life from being exposed.
Read More »

ATVOD and On Demand TV

Written by Michael Coyle on 01 July 2011

Frankie Boyle and Playboy's Climax 3 highlights the differences required for adult services.
Read More »

Choice of law clause

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 June 2011

I am often asked whether a client can apply the laws of England and Wales in the event of a dispute. For example what happens if one party wishes Scottish law to apply but our client wants English law to apply? The only party that can apply the choice of court is a court of course.
Read More »

The end of the Tweet

Written by Michael Coyle on 21 May 2011

The high court yesterday granted an order against Twitter for disclosure of those persons tweeting.
Read More »

Max Mosley goes to European Court

Written by Michael Coyle on 10 May 2011

Today the European Court of Human Rights has rejected Max Mosley's ('MM') application concerning Article 8 seeking an introduction in to English law that would legally bind the media into notifying an individual when an article discloses information about him/her.
Read More »

British Banks Lose Judicial Review

Written by Aneela Akbar on 09 May 2011

The UK banks have lost judicial review on the miss-selling of Payment Protection Insurance and are now made to contact victims of this scandal even if they have not made a complaint.
Read More »

Kingspan v Rockwool

Written by Inam Ali on 10 March 2011

A look at the recent case of Kingspan v Rockwool which dealt with issues of trade mark infringement and comparative advertising.
Read More »

JIH wins anonymity appeal

Written by Aneela Akbar on 31 January 2011

An established sportsman known as JIH has won rights to anonymity over sex life claims today at a court appeal.
Read More »

Lush attacked by hackers

Written by Aneela Akbar on 26 January 2011

The cosmetics website lush has been suspended after hackers successfully attacked the website having targeted it for several months.
Read More »

Miriam O'Rielly wins ageism case against BBC

Written by Aneela Akbar on 13 January 2011

The BBC presenter Miriam O’Reilly aged 53, well known to host the Countryfile show has won her battle at the Employment Tribunal after she claimed that the BBC had discriminated against her for being ‘too old’.
Read More »

Exception to without prejudice rule

Written by Paul Bicknell on 01 December 2010

Article takes a look at the case of Oceanbulk Shipping & Trading SA (Respondent) V TMT Asia Ltd & Ors [2010] UKSC 44 which found a new exception to the without prejudice rule.
Read More »

Ofcom Revoke Adult TV Licence

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 26 November 2010

The Office of Communications (Ofcom) which regulates communications in the UK has revoked the licence of 4 Adult TV channels.
Read More »

Tate & Lyle v Roquette Freres 2010 EWC 2010

Written by Jean-Michel Omanga on 27 October 2010

The case related to the validity of a European patent to Roquette Freres. The patent described processes for synthesising a sugar substitute maltitol by hydrogenation of maltose.
Read More »

The fight over the Lotus name

Written by Jean-Michel Omanga on 20 October 2010

This article discusses the dispute which has arisen over the right to the grid under the name Team Lotus between Lotus Ventures and Group Lotus.
Read More »

Farrall v Kordowski [2010] EWHC 2436

Written by Nesa Ahmed on 18 October 2010

Defamation - The claimant applied for an interim injunction in order to restrict the publication of defamatory words appearing on the website - solicitorsfromhell.co.uk, run by the respondent Kordowski.
Read More »

Google can use brand names in search advertising.

01 October 2010

In the Google France Sarl v Louis Vuitton Malletier SA (C-236/08) [2010] E.T.M.R. 30 appeal case, the ECJ held that by allowing advertisers to purchase their competitors trade marks in the form of keywords Google has not infringed trade mark law
Read More »

BBC Success in TV Format Infringement Claim

Written by Ben Evans on 09 September 2010

After an unsuccessful case in the High Court last week the BBC have at least been successful in a case this week. Robert Meakin brought a claim for copyright infringement against the BBC on the basis that the BBC alledgedly copied his idea for a game-show.
Read More »

The Stig Unveiled

Written by Ben Evans on 06 September 2010

The media has been hot with reports of the unveiling of the Stig. Petrolheads will know this character from BBC Two car show Top Gear, more recently however the Stig and more importantly who actually is the Stig has recently been the cause for a High Court battle.
Read More »

Trafigura fined in Dutch court

Written by Tim Mount on 25 July 2010

Trafigura back in court after marathon UK outing, this time being fined one million euros for the illegal dumping of toxic waste in Ivory Coast, alleged to have caused injury.
Read More »

Mother stranded in Pakistan

Written by Tim Mount on 27 June 2010

Mrs Justice Mary Hogg rules Pakistani mother was taken away by force from the UK and her 2 month old prematurely born baby, and deliberately stranded without her documents at her parent's house in Pakistan.
Read More »

PCC Rules in Favour of Loaded

Written by Ben Evans on 13 May 2010

The Press Compaints Commission (PCC) have found in favour of the men's magazine 'Loaded' over the use of photos of a 15 year old which had been uploaded to social networking site Bebo.
Read More »

Unreasonable Liability Clause

Written by Ben Evans on 13 May 2010

The High Court has ruled that a clause in a software contract to the effect that customers could not take any action against it for the poor performance of the software was unfiar and thus could not be enforced.
Read More »

Dee v The Telegraph

Written by Ben Evans on 07 May 2010

A professional tennis player dubbed the "world's worst tennis pro" has lost in a claim against the Telegraph newspaper.
Read More »

Database Rights and Football Fixtures

Written by Ben Evans on 30 April 2010

A High Court case has decided that there are no database rights in fixure lists for English and Scottish football leagues but instead they do benefit from copyright protection.
Read More »

Twentieth Century Fox (and others) v Newzbin [2010]

Written by Ben Evans on 15 April 2010

Twentieth Century Fox v Newzbin [2010], the judgement for this case was released a few weeks ago and has already sent shockwaves through the industry. This article considers the judgement and it's effects on service providers.
Read More »

Green Day Image Dispute

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 06 April 2010

It has been reported that legal action has been commenced against the popular band Green Day.
Read More »

Becker v Becker

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 01 April 2010

The trade mark opposition dispute between Harman Int Industries and Barbara Becker rumbles on.
Read More »

Burberry v TJ Maxx et al

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 30 March 2010

It has been reported that three stores operated by TJX Cos (TJ Maxx, Marshalls and HomeGoods stores) are subject to a legal action by Burberry.
Read More »

A Marvel of a Claim

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 25 March 2010

The dispute between the owners of the Marvel Comics and the heirs to one of its creators appears to be rumbling on.
Read More »

Sugababes - Battle of the Bands

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 23 March 2010

Former Sugababes member Mutya Buena has applied to the European Trade Mark Office (OHIM) for an EU trade mark registration for the term 'Sugababes'.
Read More »

Boom Boom Claim

Written by Ben Evans on 12 March 2010

The Black Eyed Peas have reportedly been accused of plagiarism by rapper Phoenix Phenom and songwriter Manfred Mohr.
Read More »

Markerstudy v Endsleigh

Written by Ben Evans on 07 March 2010

The High Court has ruled that a contractual liability cap applies to contractual interest but not to statutory interest.
Read More »

Stelios and Pinocchio

Written by Ben Evans on 20 February 2010

The founder of budget airline easyJet is in a legal dispute with the chief executive of rivals Ryanair.
Read More »

Jan Moir Cleared By PCC

Written by Ben Evans on 20 February 2010

The Press Complaints Commission (PCC) has decided that an article in the Daily Mail about the death of Stephen Gately did not break the rules for editors.
Read More »

Google and Goojje

Written by Ben Evans on 20 February 2010

Google are in a trade mark dispute over a Chinese website called 'Goojje'.
Read More »

Defamation and Wedding Singers

Written by Ben Evans on 08 February 2010

A case involving a group of wedding singers and their booking agents is set to trigger the Supreme court to consider what consitutes 'fair comment'.
Read More »

John Terry and Super Injunctions

Written by Ben Evans on 08 February 2010

The recent High Court hearing regarding ex England football captain John Terry has received constant media speculation regarding the law of privacy in the UK.
Read More »

Super Injunctions

Written by Michael Coyle on 01 February 2010

England and Chelsea captain John Terry lost in his attempts at continuing with an injunction previously granted a week last Friday after the high court overturned a superinjunction yesterday.
Read More »

Case T-460/07

Written by Ben Evans on 21 January 2010

Nokia have failed in their attempts to register the mark 'Life Blog'.
Read More »

Damages awarded against Microsoft

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 30 December 2009

It has been reported that Microsoft has been ordered to pay a Canadian Software company $290.00 million dollars for patent infringement.
Read More »

Manson Case Settled

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 28 December 2009

The ongoing dispute between the performer Marilyn Manson and his former band mate Stephen Bier has reportedly been settled.
Read More »

Debt Recover - The Steps

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 22 December 2009

Bad debt is a problem suffered by most businesses. A bad debt is where the business is owed money for services or goods rendered.
Read More »

Boo Hoo and Trade Mark infringement

Written by Michael Coyle on 15 November 2009

Wasabi Frog Ltd sucessfully restrained Miss Boo Ltd and Gulfraz Mohammed from trading under or by reference to the marks or domain names "Miss Boo", "miss.boo.co.uk" or from using any of the marks or domain names "boohoo", "boohoo.com" and "boo", including a requirement that the website at www.missboo.co.uk is also disabled.
Read More »

Nokia to sue Apple

Written by Michael Coyle on 22 October 2009

Nokia has a huge IP portfolio. It has today commenced legal action against Apple. Let battle commence!
Read More »

All in the font

Written by Michael Coyle on 15 October 2009

The Font Bureau has issued a claim against NBC and CNBC for copyright and trade mark infringements.
Read More »

Fierce v. Sasha Fierce

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 05 October 2009

Abercrombie and Fitch to sue R&B singer Beyonce for trade mark infringement, unfair competition and deceptive trade practices.
Read More »

Sprinkles Cupcakes Objects to Sprinkles Yogurt

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 10 September 2009

The Sprinkles Cupcakes store has 16 registered trade marks and 6 further trade marks pending registration in the US. What options are open to the new chain of frozen yogurt stores, 'Sprinkles Yogurt', is there an infringement?
Read More »

Apple Loses Mighty Mouse

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 28 August 2009

The company Man & Machine Inc. has recently announced its trade mark MIGHTY MOUSE was registered with the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
Read More »

File sharer fined in the US

Written by Michael Coyle on 02 August 2009

Another file sharer has been fined, this time the fine was $675,000 that is $22,500 for each infringement we have the details inside.
Read More »

National Portrait Gallery Takes Action

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 15 July 2009

It has been reported this week that the National Portrait Gallery has threatened to take legal action against an individual who downloaded 3,014 high resolution images from its website.
Read More »

Mosquito Nets

Written by Thomas Brereton on 04 July 2009

Ex - employees of company Vestergaard are being accused of misuse of confidential information in relation to new mosquito nets.
Read More »

Legal Action against Google

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 03 July 2009

A software company has taken action against Google for trade mark infringement relating to Google AdWords campaigns.
Read More »

Equal Pay Claim Pays Off

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 25 June 2009

A decision by the Employment Appeal Tribunal that 300 men were discriminated against because they were paid lower than women in their profession has potentially opened up the floodgates for thousands of similar claims.
Read More »

Maltesers Case & Passing Off

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 23 June 2009

It was held recently that the well know confectionary producers Mars have become a 'victim of its own success' leading to a claim for Passing Off being rejected.
Read More »

Court of Appeal Decision - Law Society Complaint & Confidentiality

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 22 June 2009

The Court of Appeal has held (in dismissing an appeal) that a Barrister who made a complaint against his instructing Solicitor did not owe a duty of care to the Solicitor by not disclosing details of the outcome of the adjudication when the content of the complaint against the Solicitor did not contain a private subject matter.
Read More »

New Kids on the Block - Trade Mark Dispute

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 17 June 2009

It has been reported that New Kids on the Block has instigated legal proceedings in the U.S District Court in New York over the attempted registration/ use of its name as a trade mark.
Read More »

Warning letters are not working

Written by Andrew Wilde on 10 June 2009

The guardian today reports that sending warning letters to those people accused of filesharing will do little to stop them from continuing with the activity - see inside for details.
Read More »

The Times to appeal High Court fine

Written by Jane Coyle on 26 May 2009

The Times has said that it will appeal after it was fined 15,000 pounds in the High Court for contempt of court over two articles published last December.
Read More »

Daimler AG v Sany Group Co Ltd

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 25 May 2009

Trade marks; Infringement; Degrees of similarity and dissimilarity between trade marks and specified goods; Incomplete evidence; Appropriateness of summary determination.
Read More »

EBay win counterfeit case

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 23 May 2009

The High Court has ruled that eBay was not legally accountable for the sale of counterfeit L'Oreal cosmetics.
Read More »

UK infringes Data Protection laws

Written by Michael Coyle on 12 April 2009

The EU Commission has written to the UK requesting that they act upon the unlawful interceptions as they are in breach of the data protection act 1988.
Read More »

Banks fight on

Written by Michael Coyle on 05 April 2009

The Abbey National et al continue to fight on against the OFT and are appealing to the House of Lords.
Read More »

Scrbd.com raises Copyright questions

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 03 April 2009

www.scribd.com is asked to remove Harry Potter novels from its site by author J. K. Rowling. And a look at the laws of Copyright in the relevant jurisdictions.
Read More »

Apple Fights for 'MacPro' in Australia

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 01 April 2009

The Californian based company Apple has taken action in the Australian federal Court to challenge a decision by Australia's trade marks regulator over intellectual property rights to the trademark 'MacPro'.
Read More »

It's no to GUCCI in Sweden

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 20 March 2009

The House of Gucci, better known as simply Gucci, considered by many in the fashion industry to be one of the most famous, prestigious, and easily recognizable fashion brands, is left without trade mark protection of its emblem, two G's face to face, in Sweden.
Read More »

Sci Fi Channel Rebrands to SYFY

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 19 March 2009

The Sci Fi Channel, an American channel part of the entertainment conglomerate NBC Universal, specializing in science fiction programs, has announced that it is planning on changing its name to Syfy.
Read More »

Google/Luis Vuitton Case Still Pending Before ECJ

Written by Waheedan Jariwalla on 17 March 2009

A decision is expected by June 2010 from the European Court of Justice (ECJ) stemming from the French Supreme Court regarding the use of sponsored keywords in the Louis Vuitton v. Google France case.
Read More »

Banks lose their Appeal

Written by Michael Coyle on 26 February 2009

The 8 banks which appealed the OFTs right to investigate whether or not their charges were fair lost the right to challenge when their appeal was rejected.
Read More »

Privacy jargon blasted

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 February 2009

The Information Commissioner has appealed for business to drop the legal jargon and explain in clear terms what you intend to do with data.
Read More »

Pirates beware

Written by Michael Coyle on 12 February 2009

ISPs will soon be on the front front and tackling those pirates
Read More »

Commercial Lease Forfeiture

Written by Tim Mount on 06 February 2009

Apparently more and more business closures seem likely in today's financial climate. And accompanying rent arrears. Read our overview of what may happen in such situations.
Read More »

celine and celine

Written by Michael Coyle on 06 February 2009

The question has been asked by a French Court for the Advocate General's opinion as whether a trademark is infringed by a trader who has registered a name as a word trade mark in respect of certain goods, against another trader who, without consent, has adopted the same name as a company name and shop sign in the context of a business marketing goods of the same kind.
Read More »

Defamation on Blog sites

Written by Ben Evans on 01 February 2009

An interesting case decided in the High Court in relation to a defamation claim arising from comments written in a Blog website.
Read More »

Right to privacy

Written by Michael Coyle on 29 January 2009

An interesting case originating from Greece highlights an individual's right to privacy.
Read More »

Yahoo is Sued by the FA

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 January 2009

Several football governing bodies in the UK are threatening to sue Yahoo for publishing fixture lists without their permission.
Read More »

Warning over taking photographs in public

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 January 2009

The ongoing debate on whether people are free to take photographs in public places has culminated in Labour MP Austin Mitchell who has tabled an Early Day Motion (EDM) in the House of Commons to consider the issues relating to police action against lawful photography in public areas.
Read More »

Children and Contracts

Written by Izaz Ali on 19 December 2008

This note looks at minor and their ability to contract and the enforceability of the contract.
Read More »

New UKIPO Tribunal

Written by Corinne Day on 17 October 2008

A new tribunal service introduced by the UK Intellectual Property Office to hear complaints against persons that register company names opportunistically,
Read More »

Chancery Division

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 11 October 2008

The Chancery Division of the High Court is based in the Thomas More Building at the Royal Courts of Justice in London and is divided between Chancery Chambers and Bankruptcy and Companies Court.
Read More »

Validity of a Contract

Written by Izaz Ali on 28 September 2008

This brief note outlines the reasons for which the validity of a contract can be challenged.
Read More »

Privilege What Is It?

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 26 September 2008

Litigation privilege relates to communications when litigation is pending or in contemplation and where the sole or dominant purpose of the communications is the obtaining of legal advice or conducting the litigation (Waugh v British Railways Board [1980] AC 521). The burden of establishing privilege lies on the party claiming it.
Read More »

Security for Costs

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 24 September 2008

Section 25 of the Civil Procedure Rules allows a Defendant to apply to the court for Security of Costs.
Read More »

County Court Claims and Costs

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 10 September 2008

Before you take civil action against another person or company via the County Court it is important to consider the issues of costs.
Read More »

I have Been Defamed over the Internet

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 06 September 2008

Due to the emergence and popularity of web blogs/forums and user orientated websites defamation over the internet has become an increasingly common concern.
Read More »

Defamation And Making Amends

Written by Michael Coyle on 03 September 2008

Tesco was again back in the news this week but it concerned defamatory comments and a claim against the Guardian.
Read More »

Giving Evidence

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 29 August 2008

The object of this note is to help you consider and prepare to give evidence.
Read More »


Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 29 August 2008

Agreements reached in mediation are enforceable as contracts if the requirements for a valid contract are satisfied. This means that parties following mediation will seek to formalise the terms of mediation as a contract.
Read More »

Methods of settlement using documents

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 29 August 2008

Once parties have reached a settlement, that is, an offer to settle has been accepted or the parties have agreed to settle on certain terms, there are a several ways in which the settlement can be concluded and documented.
Read More »

Contract Law: Battle of the Forms

Written by Ben Evans on 14 August 2008

This is the third in a series of articles on contract law. The previous two have looked at the rules regarding offer and acceptance, this short note considers some of the problems associated with offer and acceptance.
Read More »

Contract Law: The Acceptance

Written by Ben Evans on 13 August 2008

The second in this series of articles on the basics of contract law looks at acceptance of an offer. We have already seen in the last article that in order for there to be a valid contract there must be a valid acceptance.
Read More »

Contract Law: The Offer

Written by Ben Evans on 12 August 2008

This is the first in a series of articles explaining the basics of contract law. Contract law governs the regulation of trade take the following for example: "contract law has many 'purposes', but the central one is to support and to control the millions of agreements that collectively make up the 'market economy'".
Read More »

Mediation is the way forward

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 30 July 2008

Mediation is the process of resolving a dispute by using a third party who is "impartial". The purpose of mediation is to find terms of settlement that will lead to an acceptable resolution to the dispute or claim. The process of mediation involves parties assessing the claim against any defence to solve the overall dispute.
Read More »

Without Prejudice

Written by Izaz Ali on 09 July 2008

The legal scope, of the "without prejudice" maxim, and as to when it can be challenged, including,the ambit of what is known as the ambit of the unambiguous impropriety exception.
Read More »

Civil Litigation - What is the Multi Track?

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 25 June 2008

Multi-track claims involve court claims and claimants that wish to seek awards that value more than £15,000.00 or court cases that will result in a lengthy trial with considerable amounts of evidence.
Read More »

Mediation - Part 1

Written by Michael Coyle on 18 June 2008

A recent Court of Appeal case illustrates the importance of considering ADR and in particular when should the court impose a costs sanction against a successful litigant on the grounds that he has refused to take part in an alternative dispute resolution.
Read More »

Civil Litigation - What is the Small Track?

Written by Riyaz Jariwalla on 10 June 2008

The small claims track is a moderate measure, a process that takes place in the county court for dealing with cases in which one or more parties have been unable to resolve their disputes by other measures.
Read More »

Solicitors Costs

Written by Michael Coyle on 14 May 2008

I am often asked to explain or justify legal costs in relation to litigation in the High Court. Mr Justice Floyd has recently provided an interesting Judgement. It is a must read.
Read More »

Fast or Multi-Track

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 08 May 2008

When a claim is filed over a commercial dispute such as a debt it will be allocated to a certain track.
Read More »

Enforcing a Foreign Judgement

Written by Michael Coyle on 17 September 2007

Enforcement in the High Court of a foreign judgement is governed by the Civil Procedure Rules Parts 70 and 74 together with RSC Orders 17, 45 to 47 and 52 as in Schedule 1 to the CPR.
Read More »

Legal Disputes

Written by Michael Coyle on 03 September 2007

You can start a civil legal action in the county court, or in the High Court, depending on the circumstances of the case.
Read More »

Solicitors’ costs

Written by Michael Coyle on 23 August 2007

Legal costs can be very difficult to understand even for the solicitors. The general principle is the loser pays the winners costs but it is never as simple as this.
Read More »

Is a Photograph sensitive?

Written by Michael Coyle on 17 August 2007

Is a photograph and the information it contains sensitive personal data within the meaning of s.2 of the data protection act 1998?
Read More »

Font Piracy

Written by Ben Evans on 16 August 2007

Blizzard Entertainment is being sued by Founder Electronics over alleged “font piracy”.
Read More »

Breach of Contract?

Written by Izaz Ali on 08 August 2007

A breach of contract will result in, amongst other remedies, damages to put the claimant in the position he would have been in had the contract been performed.
Read More »

What to do if you find a copy of your product on ebay

Written by Ben Evans on 07 August 2007

Over the last few years ebay has become a household name, offering people the chance to easily and quickly auction a range of items from socks to cars. But whilst its ease of use and access are one of its main assets these come at a price, mainly counterfeit products.
Read More »

Is ebay liable?

Written by Michael Coyle on 06 August 2007

We all agree that the Internet has been a good thing both from a personal and business perspective. The latter has seen a phenomenal growth. However it has also exacerbated the problem of infringement of intellectual property rights (IPRs).
Read More »

Without Prejudice?

Written by Aneela Akbar on 24 July 2007

The legal scope, of the "without prejudice" maxim, and as to when it can be challenged, including, the ambit of what is known as the ambit of the unambiguous impropriety exception.
Read More »

Google and Privacy

Written by Michael Coyle on 13 July 2007

While Google’s legal counsel has expressed a willingness to co-operate it will still be concerned with The EC Article 29 Data Protection Working Party’s letter to it concerning its privacy practices.
Read More »

Spammers beware!

Written by Michael Coyle on 09 July 2007

The Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill, has brought the introduction of custodial sentences for offences for the misuse of personal data under section 55 of the Data Protection Act 1988 (DPA) a step closer.
Read More »

You Say We Pay

Written by Ben Evans on 09 July 2007

The telephone service provider behind the Richard and Judy phone in competition ‘you say we pay’ has been fined a record £150,000, the largest fine ever imposed on a premium rate phone regulator.
Read More »

No Cable

Written by Ben Evans on 06 July 2007

Dell have been ordered to change their printer advertising following a customer complaint.
Read More »

Battle over food menu

Written by Steph Mekwuye on 03 July 2007

Since the opening of Pearl Oyster Bar by Rachel Charles in the West Village 10 years ago, the chef watched the arrival of a string of restaurants she considers “knockoffs” of her own.
Read More »

Privacy Protection from the OECD

Written by Ben Evans on 02 July 2007

The member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) have agreed to a plan which will see them co-operating to uphold privacy laws amidst increasing amounts of cross border data transfer.
Read More »

Jordan and Dowie

Written by Michael Coyle on 15 June 2007

Simon Jordan the owner of Crystal Palace yesterday claimed victory in his dispute with Iain Dowie Northern Ireland legend and all round looker.
Read More »

Everything is OK Catherine!

Written by Jody Tsigarides on 03 May 2007

The recent judgement in the House of Lords appeal case involving Catherine Zeta Jones, Michael Douglas and Hello magazine has taken a dramatic swing.
Read More »

Seager Limited v Copydex Limited [1967] 2 All ER 415

Written by Izaz Ali on 11 April 2007

In the above case Lord Denning MR established the principle that even if you do not have a confidentiality agreement in place, under equity law a person who has received information in confidence cannot take unfair advantage of it.
Read More »

Intellectual Property Trade Marks and Crime

Written by Daniel Doherty on 09 January 2003

Intellectual Property Crime The Copyright, Etc. and Trade Marks (Offences and Enforcement) Act 2002 The Copyright, Etc. and Trade Marks (Offences and Enforcement) Act 2002 (the "Act") received Royal Assent on July 24 2002 and is expected to come into force by September/October. This date has been set to allow the government to disseminate information to public sector enforcers.
Read More »

Silhouette bad for Europe

08 January 2003

Silhouette Decision Bad For Europe Will the Silhouette Decision Cause Bad Economics in Europe? While the development of a doctrine of international exhaustion at a community level seems unlikely in relation to trade marks following the ECJ's decision in Silhouette, there is nonetheless an arguable case that since the ECJ did not consider whether there was a basis of international exhaustion at community level, the point might be to consider afresh. This is especially since the ECJ does not apply strict rule of precedence so that the ECJ could even reconsider the position with regards to trademarks in the future case.
Read More »

More news on Silhouette

Written by Michael Coyle on 06 January 2003

International Exhaustion: Seeing Through the Spectacles The debate as to whether the Directive was to be interpreted in light of international exhaustion was the fundamental question in the Decision C-355/96 Silhouette International Scmeid gmbH v. Hartlaur Handelgesellschaft mbH.
Read More »

The Aftermath of Silhouette

Written by Michael Coyle on 05 January 2003

Since the ruling in the Silhouette case, there have been two fundamental cases on exhaustion of rights, which shall be analysed here:-
Read More »

Want to speak
to someone?

Complete the form below and we’ll call you back free of charge.

Visual Captcha